# Best Gravel Suppliers in Highland Mills, NY in 2026: The Buyer's Shortlist

By Armen Suny (https://www.linkedin.com/in/asuny/, https://armenarmen.com) · Published 2026-10-13 · Updated 2026-10-14
Source: https://goodgravel.com/suppliers/states/new-york/highland-mills/best

The best gravel supplier in Highland Mills, NY right now is Kassel Supply Inc, which scores 60 of 100 on our checklist and is best for the widest selection. This shortlist ranks all 3 gravel suppliers we list in Highland Mills using data you can check on each listing: what they stock, whether they publish prices, whether they deliver, and how easy they are to reach. Partners pay to be featured above the list, but nobody can pay for a higher rank.

## Key Takeaways

- Kassel Supply Inc is the top pick in Highland Mills, with 60 of 100 points. It earns its place on material selection, delivery, and contact details.
- 1 of 3 suppliers deliver. Delivery usually starts at one truckload, about 10 tons, so smaller jobs are often pickup only.
- No Highland Mills supplier on this list publishes per-ton prices yet. Budget by calling two or three yards with your area and depth ready.
- Every supplier here is a landscape yard or dealer rather than a pit. Expect a wider choice of decorative rock and smaller minimum orders.
- No supplier here gives an instant online price yet, so plan on calling. Work out your tons first so the quote takes one call instead of three.

## What a Gravel Supplier Actually Is (and What It Is Not)

A gravel supplier sells loose stone by weight or volume: crushed stone, pea gravel, river rock, base course, and decorative rock. In Highland Mills that means three kinds of business. Pits and quarries dig and crush their own stone. Landscape supply yards buy from pits and stock a wider mix in smaller piles. Building material dealers sell gravel alongside sand, soil, mulch and block.

Most sell by the ton or the cubic yard, load your trailer with a front loader, or send a dump truck. A single axle truck carries about 10 tons and a tandem 14 to 18. The price per ton drops as the order grows, and delivery is usually a flat fee by distance.

A gravel supplier is not a hardware store. Big box stores sell gravel in 0.5 cubic foot bags, which costs several times more per ton and only makes sense for a few square feet. A supplier is also not an installer. Most yards drop the stone and leave. Grading, compaction and edging are a landscaper's or contractor's job, unless the yard says it installs.

Whatever you buy, know your area and depth before you call. It is the first thing every yard will ask.

## How We Ranked These Gravel Suppliers

Each supplier is scored out of 100 from its GoodGravel listing. No supplier can pay for a higher rank; partners pay only for the featured slot above.

| Criterion | Points | How it is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Material selection | 25 | Gravel and stone types stocked, full marks at 8 or more. |
| Published prices | 25 | Share of stocked materials with a published price per ton, yard or bag. |
| Delivery | 20 | Whether the supplier delivers. Most driveway and base jobs need a truck. |
| Owner-verified listing | 15 | Whether the business owner has claimed and confirmed the listing. Claiming is free. |
| Contact details | 15 | Phone (6 points), street address (5) and website (4) on file. |

## The Best Gravel Suppliers in Highland Mills in 2026

### 1. Kassel Supply Inc, best for the widest selection

Kassel Supply Inc is a gravel and landscape supplier in Highland Mills, NY at 1143 NY-32, Highland Mills, NY, 10930. It ranks #1 of 3 with 60 of 100 points.

It lists 9 materials: Black Shredded Mulch, Brown Shredded Mulch, Compost, Pea Gravel, Recycled Asphalt, Rip Rap, River Rock, Stone Dust, and Topsoil. It does not publish prices, so call for a quote.

It delivers. The owner has not claimed this listing yet, so details may be out of date. To order, call (845) 928-9915 or visit kasselsupply.com.

Score breakdown: material selection 25/25 (9 materials listed), published prices 0/25 (0 of 9 priced), delivery 20/20 (delivers), owner-verified listing 0/15 (unclaimed), contact details 15/15 (phone, address, and website).

**Best suited for:** Projects mixing materials, like a base course under decorative top stone. One stop instead of two yards.

Listing: https://goodgravel.com/suppliers/states/new-york/highland-mills/suppliers/kassel-supply-inc

### 2. Orange Nursery & Stone Supply, best for local pickup

Orange Nursery & Stone Supply is a gravel and landscape supplier in Highland Mills, NY at 1129 NY-32, Highland Mills, NY, 10930. It ranks #2 of 3 with 15 of 100 points.

It has not listed the materials it stocks yet, so call to confirm before you drive over.

It is pickup only, so bring a truck or trailer. The owner has not claimed this listing yet, so details may be out of date. To order, call (845) 928-2777 or visit onursery.com.

Score breakdown: material selection 0/25 (0 materials listed), published prices 0/25 (no materials listed), delivery 0/20 (pickup only), owner-verified listing 0/15 (unclaimed), contact details 15/15 (phone, address, and website).

**Best suited for:** Small jobs you can haul yourself with a pickup or trailer. Usually the cheapest way to buy a yard or two.

Listing: https://goodgravel.com/suppliers/states/new-york/highland-mills/suppliers/orange-nursery-stone-supply

### 3. Highland Sand & Gravel Inc., best for local pickup

Highland Sand & Gravel Inc. is a gravel and landscape supplier in Highland Mills, NY at 911 NY-32, Highland Mills, NY, 10930. It ranks #3 of 3 with 11 of 100 points.

It has not listed the materials it stocks yet, so call to confirm before you drive over.

It is pickup only, so bring a truck or trailer. The owner has not claimed this listing yet, so details may be out of date. To order, call (845) 928-2221.

Score breakdown: material selection 0/25 (0 materials listed), published prices 0/25 (no materials listed), delivery 0/20 (pickup only), owner-verified listing 0/15 (unclaimed), contact details 11/15 (phone and address).

**Best suited for:** Small jobs you can haul yourself with a pickup or trailer. Usually the cheapest way to buy a yard or two.

Listing: https://goodgravel.com/suppliers/states/new-york/highland-mills/suppliers/highland-sand-gravel-inc

## Side-by-Side Comparison

| # | Supplier | Score | Best for | Materials | Lowest price | Delivery | Type | Instant price | Verified |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kassel Supply Inc | 60/100 | the widest selection | 9 | Call | Yes | Yard | No | No |
| 2 | Orange Nursery & Stone Supply | 15/100 | local pickup | 0 | Call | Pickup | Yard | No | No |
| 3 | Highland Sand & Gravel Inc. | 11/100 | local pickup | 0 | Call | Pickup | Yard | No | No |

## Which Gravel Supplier Fits Your Project

| Your project | Start with | Why | Also try |
|---|---|---|---|
| Driveway, pad or road base by the truckload | Kassel Supply Inc | Highest-ranked supplier for bulk orders | Orange Nursery & Stone Supply |
| Decorative landscaping rock | Kassel Supply Inc | 9 materials to choose from | Orange Nursery & Stone Supply |
| Delivered to a home with no truck | Kassel Supply Inc | Delivers | Orange Nursery & Stone Supply |
| Pricing a project before you commit | Kassel Supply Inc | Publishes prices (0 of 9 priced) | Orange Nursery & Stone Supply |

## Frequently Asked Questions

### What is the best gravel supplier in Highland Mills?

Kassel Supply Inc ranks first on our Highland Mills shortlist with 60 of 100 points, and is best for the widest selection. The right pick still depends on your job, so check the use case table before you call.

### How much does gravel cost in Highland Mills?

Most Highland Mills suppliers here quote by phone, so there is no published local range yet. Base stone usually costs less per ton than decorative rock, and delivery is extra.

### Which Highland Mills gravel suppliers deliver?

1 of the 3 suppliers on this list deliver. Expect a minimum of about one truckload, which is 10 tons on a single axle truck and up to 18 on a tandem.

### What is the difference between a gravel pit and a landscape yard?

A pit sells straight from its own stockpile in bulk, so the price per ton is usually lower. A landscape yard buys from pits and sells smaller amounts of more kinds of rock. 0 suppliers on this list are pits.

### How can I get a gravel price in Highland Mills without calling around?

None of the Highland Mills suppliers on this list offer an instant online price yet, so call or email for a quote. Have your area, depth and delivery address ready and the yard can price it in one call.

### How much gravel do I need?

Multiply length by width by depth in feet and divide by 27 for cubic yards, then multiply by about 1.4 for tons. A 12 by 50 foot driveway at 4 inches deep needs about 7.4 cubic yards, roughly 10 tons.

### How did GoodGravel rank these suppliers?

Each supplier is scored out of 100 on material selection, published prices, delivery, owner-verified listing, and contact details. Partners pay to be featured above the list and are labelled, but no supplier can pay for a higher rank. Scores update whenever a listing changes.

## Get Free Gravel Quotes in Highland Mills

Measure your project once with the free Gravel Planner and send it to Highland Mills suppliers that deliver: https://goodgravel.com/gravel-planner