GoodGravel

#57 Gravel vs Brown Shredded Mulch: Size, Cost, and Which to Use

#57 Gravel runs about $20 per ton and Brown Shredded Mulch about $20 per ton. Compare size, drainage, compaction, and which one to use.

Overview

#57 Gravel

The 57 comes from the ASTM C33 grading table. Size #57 means most of the stone passes a 1-inch screen and stays on a #4 sieve (about 3/16 inch), with the bulk of it between 1/2 and 1 inch. It is "clean" stone, so there are no fines. That leaves about 35 percent air space in a pile, which is why it drains so well and why it stays loose on its own.

Brown Shredded Mulch

Shredded bark and wood from trees like oak, hickory, and maple. Retains moisture, suppresses weeds, and regulates soil temperature. Decomposes slowly over time, adding organic matter to the soil. Adds a natural, finished look to landscape beds.

Common Uses

#57 Gravel

  • Driveways
  • French drains
  • Concrete mix
  • Pipe bedding
  • Backfill
  • Parking pads
  • Septic systems

Brown Shredded Mulch

  • Landscape beds
  • Tree rings
  • Garden borders
  • Erosion control
  • Playground surfaces
  • Slope stabilization

Pros & Cons

#57 Gravel

  • + Cheapest useful stone at $20 to $35 per ton
  • + Stocked at every quarry in the country
  • + Drains fast, about 35 percent void space
  • + Angular pieces interlock under load
  • + Works for driveways, drains, concrete, and backfill
  • Too coarse to walk on comfortably
  • Stays loose, rolls to the edges under tires
  • Needs a finer top layer on driveways
  • Not decorative

Brown Shredded Mulch

  • + Retains soil moisture reducing watering
  • + Suppresses weed growth naturally
  • + Insulates soil temperature
  • + Decomposes to enrich soil over time
  • + Attractive natural brown color
  • Needs replenishing every 1-2 years as it decomposes
  • Can attract termites if placed against structures
  • May temporarily rob nitrogen from soil as it breaks down
  • Floats and washes away in heavy rain
  • Can develop mold in overly wet conditions

Cost Comparison

Measure #57 Gravel Brown Shredded Mulch
Per ton $20 – $35 $20 – $40
Per cubic yard $25 – $45 $25 – $45

Sizes & Colors

#57 Gravel

#57 gravel is angular crushed stone screened to 3/4 inch to 1 inch, with a few pieces down to 1/2 inch. Color depends on the quarry: gray or blue-gray limestone through the Midwest and Northeast, gray, white, and pink granite in the Southeast, tan limestone in Texas, and dark basalt in the Northwest.

Brown Shredded Mulch

Shredded strips of bark and wood, typically 1-4 inches long. Natural brown color that fades to gray over time. Double-shredded mulch is finer and mats together better, resisting wind and rain displacement.

Published February 11, 2026

Compare prices from local suppliers

Get quotes from gravel suppliers near you to find the best deal.