Black Shredded Mulch vs Crushed Stone: Size, Cost, and Which to Use

Black Shredded Mulch

Shredded hardwood mulch dyed black for a bold, modern landscape look. Rich black color makes green plants and colorful flowers stand out. Holds its color longer than brown mulch and provides the same moisture retention, weed suppression, and soil temperature regulation benefits.

Crushed Stone

Crushed stone is rock that a quarry blasted, crushed, and screened into a set size range. It costs $20 to $40 per ton in 2026, weighs 1.35 to 1.55 tons per cubic yard, and is the base under nearly every road, driveway, slab, and patio in the country. The important difference from "gravel" in the natural sense is shape: crushed stone is angular, so the pieces lock together, while natural river gravel is rounded and rolls. Almost everything sold as gravel at a quarry is crushed stone.

Black Shredded Mulch

• ✓ Landscape beds
• ✓ Tree rings
• ✓ Garden borders
• ✓ Foundation plantings
• ✓ Commercial landscaping
• ✓ Contrast beds

Crushed Stone

• ✓ Driveways
• ✓ Road base
• ✓ Concrete mix
• ✓ Drainage
• ✓ Paver base
• ✓ Backfill

Black Shredded Mulch

• + Bold black color creates striking contrast with plants
• + Holds color longer than natural brown mulch
• + Retains soil moisture reducing watering
• + Suppresses weed growth naturally
• + Insulates soil temperature

• − Dye can temporarily stain hands, concrete, and clothing
• − Needs replenishing every 1-2 years as it decomposes
• − Can attract termites if placed against structures
• − Fades to dark gray over time
• − Slightly more expensive than undyed mulch

Crushed Stone

• + Angular pieces interlock and carry weight
• + Cheapest bulk material at $20 to $40 per ton
• + A size for every job, from dust to 4-inch rock
• + Stocked at every quarry
• + Drains (clean) or packs (minus), your choice

• − Sharp edges, hard on bare feet and tires in big sizes
• − Plain gray look
• − Easy to order the wrong size
• − Larger sizes are hard to spread by hand

Black Shredded Mulch

Shredded strips of bark and wood, typically 1-4 inches long, dyed with carbon-based black colorant. The dye is non-toxic and safe for plants and pets. Double-shredded black mulch mats together better and resists displacement.

Crushed Stone

Crushed stone is sold by sieve size, from stone dust and #10 screenings (under 1/4 inch) through #8 (3/8 to 1/2 inch), #57 (3/4 to 1 inch), #4 (1 to 1.5 inches), #3 (1.5 to 2.5 inches), and #1 or #2 (2.5 to 4 inches). Every size is angular with fractured faces. Color follows the quarry: gray or blue-gray limestone, gray to pink granite, dark basalt, or tan sandstone and limestone in the South.