Black Shredded Mulch vs Topsoil
Side-by-side comparison of Black Shredded Mulch and Topsoil to help you choose the right gravel for your project.
Overview
Shredded hardwood mulch dyed black for a bold, modern landscape look. Rich black color makes green plants and colorful flowers stand out. Holds its color longer than brown mulch and provides the same moisture retention, weed suppression, and soil temperature regulation benefits.
Nutrient-rich upper layer of soil, ideal for establishing lawns, gardens, and planting beds. Quality topsoil is dark, crumbly, and full of organic matter that supports plant growth. Screened topsoil has been filtered to remove rocks, roots, and debris.
Common Uses
Black Shredded Mulch
- ✓ Landscape beds
- ✓ Tree rings
- ✓ Garden borders
- ✓ Foundation plantings
- ✓ Commercial landscaping
- ✓ Contrast beds
Topsoil
- ✓ Lawn seeding
- ✓ Garden beds
- ✓ Raised bed fill
- ✓ Landscape grading
- ✓ Sod installation
- ✓ Tree and shrub planting
Pros & Cons
Black Shredded Mulch
- + Bold black color creates striking contrast with plants
- + Holds color longer than natural brown mulch
- + Retains soil moisture reducing watering
- + Suppresses weed growth naturally
- + Insulates soil temperature
- − Dye can temporarily stain hands, concrete, and clothing
- − Needs replenishing every 1-2 years as it decomposes
- − Can attract termites if placed against structures
- − Fades to dark gray over time
- − Slightly more expensive than undyed mulch
Topsoil
- + Rich in nutrients for plant growth
- + Creates ideal growing medium
- + Dark color absorbs warmth for earlier spring planting
- + Screened options are ready to use
- + Essential for any planting project
- − Settles significantly after delivery
- − Quality varies greatly between suppliers
- − Can contain weed seeds
- − Heavy when wet
- − Should never be used as structural fill
Cost Comparison
| Measure | Black Shredded Mulch | Topsoil |
|---|---|---|
| Per ton | $25 – $45 | $12 – $30 |
| Per cubic yard | $30 – $50 | $15 – $40 |
Sizes & Colors
Black Shredded Mulch
Shredded strips of bark and wood, typically 1-4 inches long, dyed with carbon-based black colorant. The dye is non-toxic and safe for plants and pets. Double-shredded black mulch mats together better and resists displacement.
Topsoil
Fine, crumbly soil texture when screened. Dark brown to black color indicates high organic content. "Screened" topsoil has been run through a 3/8" or 1/2" screen to remove debris. Blended topsoil may include compost for extra nutrients.
Published February 11, 2026
Compare prices from local suppliers
Get quotes from gravel suppliers near you to find the best deal.